Natural History

Top 7 Most Collectible Fossils: A Guide for Collectors and Enthusiasts

30 April 2025

Alex Tweedy

Fossils offer a rare and tangible connection to prehistoric life, preserving the remains of ancient creatures and plants that lived millions of years ago. For collectors, they represent a captivating blend of science, natural history, and natural beauty. Whether displayed in museums or treasured in private collections, certain fossils remain consistently sought-after for their rarity, scientific value, and visual impact.

Below, we explore seven of the most collectable fossils on the market today and what makes each one so special.

Request a Free Fossil Valuation

Find out how much your fossils could sell for at auction. Contact our auction team for a complimentary valuation.

Tyrannosaurus Rex Teeth

Arguably the most iconic of all dinosaur fossils, Tyrannosaurus rex teeth are instantly recognisable for their sheer size, curved form, and distinctive serrated edges. These formidable “banana-shaped” teeth, some exceeding 30 cm in length, were perfectly adapted for puncturing and tearing flesh, earning the T. Rex its reputation as one of the most fearsome predators to ever walk the Earth.

What makes T. Rex teeth especially desirable to collectors is their combination of rarity, visual impact, and historic significance. With only a limited number of specimens ever discovered, primarily from the Hell Creek and Lance Formations in North America, authentic, well-preserved teeth are increasingly scarce. Many are incomplete or heavily worn from use during the dinosaur’s lifetime, so examples with intact serrations, enamel, and root structures command particular attention and higher values at auction.

Beyond their scientific value, T. Rex teeth have become cultural icons, frequently featured in museums, documentaries, and popular media. This widespread recognition fuels intense demand not just from palaeontologists, but from private collectors and natural history institutions worldwide. Whether displayed as a standalone specimen or alongside other theropod fossils, a genuine T. Rex tooth remains a crown jewel in any fossil collection.

Megalodon Teeth

These formidable fossil teeth belonged to Otodus Megalodon, a colossal prehistoric shark that ruled the oceans approximately 23 to 3.6 million years ago during the Miocene and Pliocene epochs. With estimated lengths exceeding 15 metres, and some reconstructions suggesting up to 20 metres, the Megalodon is considered one of the largest and most powerful marine predators in Earth’s history.

Megalodon teeth are among the most collectable shark fossils due to their extraordinary size, often measuring over 15 cm from root to tip. Their razor-sharp serrations and triangular profile reflect the shark’s specialised feeding adaptations, designed for tearing through the thick flesh and bone of whales and large marine mammals. In the fossil market, the finest specimens display well-preserved enamel, clear serration detail, and striking natural colour variations, ranging from jet black and slate grey to earthy browns, blues, and even hints of orange, depending on the mineral content of the surrounding sediment.

Highly photogenic and instantly impressive, Megalodon teeth are centrepieces in many fossil collections, prized by palaeontologists, amateur collectors, and interior designers alike. Larger and more pristine examples are increasingly rare, especially those from well-known fossil beds such as the Calvert Cliffs in Maryland, the Peace River in Florida, and offshore sites in North Carolina. As demand continues to rise, Megalodon teeth remain a must-have for anyone interested in prehistoric marine life or investment-grade natural history specimens.

PAST LOT

COLLECTION OF FIVE MEGALODON TEETH SOUTH CAROLINA / JAVA

MIOCENE PERIOD, 15 MILLION YEARS B.P.

Believed to have grown as large as 18 metres, the Megalodon (whose name translates as “large tooth”) was the largest shark and one of the most dominant marine predators ever to have existed. It roamed the ancient seas for around 20 million years until their extinction around 3.6 million years ago.

With skeletal remains exceptionally rare, Megalodon teeth are valuable sources of study, as well as highly decorative reminders of one of the largest and most dangerous marine creatures ever to have lived.

Elephant Bird Eggs

Among the most extraordinary and coveted subfossils in the world, elephant bird eggs are the remnants of Aepyornis Maximus, a now-extinct species of giant, flightless bird once native to the island of Madagascar. Towering up to 3 metres tall and weighing over 400 kg, the elephant bird was the heaviest bird to ever live. Its eggs, fittingly, are the largest ever recorded in the fossil record. A single egg could exceed 30 cm (12 inches) in length and hold up to 9 litres of volume, the equivalent of roughly 150 chicken eggs.

Though Aepyornis went extinct sometime between the 10th and 17th centuries, likely due to a combination of human hunting and habitat loss, its eggs were remarkably preserved in Madagascar’s arid and sandy soils. The dry environment allowed some of these massive shells to survive for centuries, often buried just beneath the surface. Most examples are found in fragmented form and require meticulous reassembly, a painstaking but rewarding process. Fully intact elephant bird eggs, however, are exceedingly rare and are considered crown jewels in natural history collections.

Their striking appearance and immense scale have captured the imagination of collectors, museums, and scientists alike. These eggs offer a direct and awe-inspiring link to a vanished species and an island ecosystem forever changed by human activity.

Ammonites

Ammonites are among the most iconic and visually striking fossils in the world. These extinct spiral-shelled marine molluscs thrived in the Earth’s oceans for over 300 million years before vanishing alongside the dinosaurs around 66 million years ago. Their widespread presence in the fossil record, combined with their intricate forms and natural beauty, has made ammonites a favourite among collectors, scientists, and designers alike.

While ammonites are relatively abundant, certain varieties are especially prized for their rarity, preservation, and aesthetic qualities:

Iridescent ammonites from the Bearpaw Formation in Alberta, Canada are among the most spectacular. Over millions of years, these specimens fossilised into ammolite, a rare and vibrant opal-like gemstone that shimmers with hues of red, green, blue, and gold. Ammolite ammonites are not only scientifically important but also highly collectable for use in jewellery and decorative art.

Pyritised ammonites, often found in parts of Germany and Russia, are preserved in iron pyrite (fool’s gold), giving them a metallic sheen that enhances their sculptural appeal. These fossils are both visually unique and geologically fascinating.

Ammonites with complex suture patterns — the intricate lines where the shell’s internal chambers joined — are especially valued for their detail and mathematical beauty. These delicate patterns reflect the evolutionary sophistication of these ancient creatures and are a testament to nature’s artistry.

The natural symmetry and spiral geometry of ammonites have long been admired for their aesthetic appeal. Whether showcased in a scientific collection, mounted as a display fossil, or incorporated into high-end interior décor, ammonites continue to captivate. Their combination of accessibility, beauty, and deep-time significance makes them a cornerstone of fossil collecting across all levels.

Fossil Crinoids from Holzmaden

Crinoids, commonly known as “sea lilies,” are marine animals belonging to the echinoderm family, making them distant relatives of starfish and sea urchins. Despite their plant-like appearance, crinoids are in fact animals, anchored to the seafloor by long, slender stalks and equipped with feathery arms used to capture plankton from the water. They first appeared over 480 million years ago and flourished particularly during the Paleozoic era, often forming dense underwater “meadows” in shallow seas.

Fossil specimens from Holzmaden, Germany, are among the most highly prized by collectors and palaeontologists alike. Preserved within the dark, fine-grained shales of the Jurassic Posidonia Formation, these crinoids are celebrated for their exceptional detail and completeness. Unlike many fossil deposits where only fragments remain, the Holzmaden crinoids are frequently found with their full stems intact and their delicate, branching arms radiating in graceful symmetry, an extraordinarily rare occurrence in the fossil record.

This level of preservation is the result of rapid burial in an anoxic, or oxygen-depleted, seabed environment, which inhibited decay and scavenging. As a result, these fossils offer an unusually vivid snapshot of life in the prehistoric oceans of around 180 million years ago. Not only are they scientifically valuable, providing insight into Jurassic marine ecosystems, but they are also visually striking—natural works of art formed over millennia.

PAST LOT

LARGE CRINOID SEA-BED PLAQUE

MOROCCO, UPPER SILURIAN, C. 420 MILLION YEARS B.P.

The plaque displaying a large number of Scyphocrinus elegans in their original matrix in an impressive state of preservation

Petrified Wood

Petrified wood is a remarkable form of fossilisation in which ancient plant material, most often trees, is gradually transformed into stone over millions of years. This process occurs when fallen trees are rapidly buried by sediment and mineral-rich water seeps into the organic tissue. Over time, the original wood structure is slowly replaced by silica and other minerals such as quartz, jasper, and opal, while preserving even the finest details of the grain, bark, and growth rings.

What makes petrified wood especially captivating is its vivid colouration. Mineral impurities introduced during the fossilisation process create a palette of natural hues: iron oxides produce reds and yellows, manganese yields blues and purples, and copper or chromium can lend shades of green. These colours, combined with the intricate preservation of the wood’s cellular structure, make each specimen uniquely beautiful - a perfect marriage of natural history and aesthetics.

Found in various regions around the world, including the United States, Madagascar, and Indonesia, petrified wood has long been prized by collectors, gem enthusiasts, and interior designers. Its durability and striking appearance make it a popular choice for decorative objects, tabletops, jewellery, and even architectural features. Beyond its visual appeal, petrified wood offers a tangible connection to Earth’s deep past—a living organism, stilled and immortalised in stone.

Cave Bear Skeletons

Complete cave bear (Ursus spelaeus) skeletons rank among the most impressive and sought-after fossils from the last Ice Age. These imposing mammals inhabited much of Europe during the Pleistocene epoch, from roughly 300,000 to 24,000 years ago. Unlike modern bears, cave bears are thought to have been largely herbivorous and are closely related to the modern brown bear (Ursus arctos), though distinct in both size and skeletal structure.

As their name suggests, cave bears frequently lived and died in limestone caves, environments that proved ideal for the preservation of their remains. The cool, stable conditions within these subterranean chambers helped protect bones from weathering, scavengers, and time, resulting in some of the most complete fossil bear skeletons known to science. Notable discoveries have been made in Austria, Romania, Slovenia, and across the Carpathian Mountains, where cave systems yielded hundreds of specimens, some buried en masse, others preserved in situ.

Mounted skeletons are particularly dramatic when posed in an upright, rearing position, often standing more than 3.5 metres tall. This towering stature, coupled with the bear’s powerful skeletal frame and impressive skull, makes it a commanding centrepiece for museums, private collections, and natural history exhibitions. However, while partial skeletons are relatively common, complete mounts composed entirely of bones from a single individual are extremely rare. These unified specimens are especially prized by collectors for their scientific integrity and display impact.

More than just a relic of the Ice Age, the cave bear represents a fascinating chapter in Europe’s prehistoric wildlife, a creature that once shared the landscape with Neanderthals and early modern humans, and whose remains continue to fuel both research and wonder.

Natural History Auctions | Meteorites, Fossils & More

Department

Natural History & Fossils

ABOUT THE AUTHOR